Mercedes A-Class vs Volkswagen Golf: Used Car Comparison

Choosing between two of the most popular hatchbacks on the road can feel a bit like picking a favourite song – they’re both great, but one just feels right. The Mercedes A-Class and the Volkswagen Golf have long been rivals, each offering a unique blend of style, performance, and practicality. So, which one should you choose?

Don't worry, we're here to help you figure that out. We’ll break down the key differences between a used Mercedes-Benz A-Class and a used Volkswagen Golf, from boot space to running costs. Let's find the perfect match for you.

How do they compare in terms of size and style?

At a glance, the A-Class and the Golf are very similar in size. They both fit neatly into the mid-size hatchback category, making them great all-rounders for city driving and longer journeys.

• The A-Class is a fraction longer, but we're only talking about a couple of centimetres.
• They are both just over two metres wide, including their mirrors.
• The Golf stands slightly taller than the sleeker, lower-slung A-Class.

While their dimensions are nearly identical, their design philosophies are quite different. The A-Class often carries that premium Mercedes flair, with a design that borrows from its more expensive siblings. The Golf, on the other hand, has a classic, understated look that has been refined over generations. It’s confident without being flashy.

What about their interiors and tech?

Stepping inside is where you’ll notice some of the biggest differences in this hatchback comparison.

Mercedes-Benz A-Class

The A-Class aims to impress with a cabin inspired by high-end Mercedes models. You get a touch of luxury with stylish air vents and a generally premium feel.

• Infotainment: Most models from 2015 onwards come with a tablet-style screen. Newer versions feature larger, more impressive displays.
• Connectivity: Look for models with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto to easily sync your smartphone for music and navigation.
• Feel: While it looks the part, some of the plastics might not feel as high-quality as you’d expect, but the overall impression is one of sophistication.

Volkswagen Golf

The Golf’s interior is a lesson in functional, solid design. It feels incredibly well-built and is designed to make your life easier.

• Infotainment: The system is known for being user-friendly and intuitive. Post-2017 models often include Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
• Quality: It may not have the initial "wow" factor of the A-Class, but the materials are robust and built to last. Everything feels exactly where it should be.
• Atmosphere: The cabin feels more premium than many other family car options in its class, striking a great balance between comfort and common sense.

Which car is the most practical?

For many, a hatchback needs to be a practical daily driver. This is where the Volkswagen Golf starts to pull ahead.

The Golf offers more generous passenger space, particularly for those in the back. While two adults can sit comfortably in the rear of a Golf for a decent journey, they might find the back of an A-Class a bit snug.

Both cars do a great job with storage. You’ll find useful cubbies, deep door pockets for your water bottles, and space under the armrest for bits and bobs. But if you often carry friends or family, the Golf’s extra room makes it a more accommodating choice.

What about boot space?

When it’s time for the big shop or a weekend away, boot space is a deal-breaker. Again, the Golf has the edge here.

• Volkswagen Golf: Most versions offer a generous 380 litres of boot space. This is plenty for weekly groceries, a couple of suitcases, or a pushchair.
• Mercedes-Benz A-Class: The A-Class offers 341 litres. It’s still a useful amount of space, but that 39-litre difference can be noticeable.
• Special Editions: It's worth noting that hybrid or electric versions of the Golf (like the GTE or e-Golf) have less boot space (around 272 litres) because of the battery. If you need even more room, the Golf Estate is a fantastic option with a huge 605-litre boot.

Which is better to drive?

Both cars are enjoyable to drive, but they offer slightly different experiences behind the wheel.

A used Mercedes-Benz A-Class often strikes a good balance between comfort and sporty handling. It feels composed on motorways and can be fun on winding country roads. It’s a versatile performer that handles most situations with ease.

A used Volkswagen Golf is famous for its smooth and refined ride. It feels responsive, the engines are generally quieter, and it soaks up bumps in the road beautifully. It’s an incredibly easy and relaxing car to drive, which is why it’s such a popular choice.

For those looking for more excitement, both models have high-performance versions. The Golf GTI and Golf R are legendary hot hatches, while Mercedes offers powerful AMG versions of the A-Class for a serious thrill.

Ownership Costs

When thinking about your budget, it’s important to look beyond the initial price. The Volkswagen Golf generally proves to be the more economical option to own.

The A-Class, being a premium brand, can sometimes have slightly higher running costs. However, both cars offer good fuel efficiency. Diesel versions of the A-Class can achieve over 60mpg, while the petrols can reach into the 50s.

The Golf provides a wider range of engine choices, including petrol, diesel, plug-in hybrid, and even fully electric models, giving you more options to find a car that suits your budget and driving habits.

Which is the safest and most reliable?

Your peace of mind is what matters most. Both the A-Class and the Golf scored a full five stars in their Euro NCAP safety tests back in 2012, and later models come with modern safety features like automatic emergency braking.

When it comes to reliability, the Volkswagen Golf has historically performed very well in owner satisfaction surveys. It has a long-standing reputation for being a dependable and trustworthy car. While the A-Class is also a solid vehicle, the Golf often ranks higher for long-term reliability, making it a reassuring choice for a used family car.

The Verdict: A-Class or Golf?

So, which car comes out on top in this hatchback comparison?

The Mercedes-Benz A-Class is a stylish, comfortable, and desirable car that brings a touch of luxury to the hatchback class. If brand prestige and a high-end interior are at the top of your list, you won't be disappointed.

However, the Volkswagen Golf is arguably the better all-rounder. It’s more practical, has a roomier interior, offers a smoother ride, and comes with a wider variety of engine options. It’s also typically more affordable to buy and run, without making you feel like you’ve compromised on quality.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. If you value practicality and an easy ownership experience, the Volkswagen Golf is likely the best fit. If you prefer a bit more style and badge appeal, the Mercedes-Benz A-Class is an excellent option.

Ready to find your perfect hatchback? Browse our range of high-quality used Volkswagen Golf cars and used Mercedes-Benz A-Class cars.